Franciscan University Sues Government for Right “to Live the Faith We Believe”  Franciscan University joins rising tide, including the Archdioceses of Washington, D.C., New York, and St. Louis, seeking to overturn the HHS mandate.

STEUBENVILLE, OHIO—Franciscan University of Steubenville announced today that it has filed a federal lawsuit against Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius and the Obama administration. The lawsuit, which was unanimously approved by Franciscan’s Board of Trustees, challenges the Obama administration’s unprecedented mandate that attacks the freedom to practice religion without government interference.

Under the HHS mandate, employers must provide insurance coverage that includes abortion-inducing drugs, as well as contraceptives and sterilization procedures. Franciscan University maintains that the requirement to fund and facilitate such activities violates its core religious and moral convictions as a Catholic university.

“Franciscan University’s mission is and always has been to teach from the heart of the Church,” said University President Father Terence Henry, TOR. “The Obama administration’s mandate is a grave threat to our ability to carry out that mission. It makes it impossible for us to operate freely as a Catholic institution without overbearing and invasive governmental interference.”

The lawsuit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio, seeks to have the mandate declared unconstitutional and enjoin the government from enforcing the requirement.

In addition to Franciscan University’s lawsuit, 42 other separate plaintiffs filed a total of 12 lawsuits today in U.S. District courts around the country. Those plaintiffs are all Catholic organizations and include Catholic dioceses, schools, universities, and charitable organizations. Numbered among the plaintiffs are the Archdioceses of New York, Washington, D.C., and St. Louis, as well as the Dioceses of Dallas, Ft. Worth, Rockville Centre, Pittsburgh, and the Michigan Catholic Conference, which represents all seven dioceses in the state.

“The Church is speaking with one unified voice on this issue,” said Father Henry. “Every single American bishop has condemned this unjust mandate as an unconscionable violation of religious liberty. If allowed to stand, it will coerce Christians into cooperating with acts that violate core tenets of our faith.”

When first proposed in August 2011 by the Department of Health and Human Services, the mandate was met by strong objections from numerous Catholic bishops, hospitals, and institutions. Although a small exemption for some religious institutions was written into the original proposal, it was too narrow to cover the vast majority of them, particularly those, like Catholic universities, which both employ and serve people of other faiths or no faith at all. The mandate effectively puts the federal government in the position of deciding which organizations are “religious enough.”

At the time, Franciscan University took a public stand opposing the proposed rule. Then, as now, Franciscan University objected to the mandate, noting that the government placed it and other religious institutions in an untenable position.

“Throughout our 65-year history, Franciscan University has educated people because we are Catholic, not because they are. And, again, because we are Catholic, Franciscan cannot provide coverage of drugs and procedures that violate Church teachings on the sanctity of life,” Father Henry said. “Under the HHS mandate and its narrow exemption, the government punishes us for reaching out to serve and employ those who do not share our faith.”

Unfortunately, in late January 2012, President Obama and HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius announced that the mandate would go into force as originally planned, with no adequate accommodations made for individuals or groups who objected on religious grounds.

Catholic and Christian institutions, however, were given one additional year to comply with the rule, a year in which they could “figure out how to violate our consciences in order to be in keeping with the law,” said Father Henry, echoing New York’s Timothy Cardinal Dolan.

“It is our hope and fervent prayer that the courts and Congress will check this monumental overstep of the Executive Branch as soon as possible,” he added.

Noting that Franciscan University did not go looking for this battle, Father Henry said the University retained Jones Day, one of the world’s largest law firms, with whom the University has had a relationship for the past twenty years, “because it has the resources to fight the government as long as it takes, and we will settle for no less than a restoration of our First Amendment right to freedom of religion.”

Father Henry concluded, “Under no circumstances can Catholics be both in compliance with this new law and at the same time live the faith that we believe. Franciscan University will continue to stand with the Church in its opposition to this mandate. Our ancestors came to America because they knew that on these shores they would be free to faithfully live what they believed. This mandate is not only a grave infringement on religious liberty; it is a betrayal of those who sacrificed to make this country what it is today.”

For more information, go to our In our In Defense of Religious Liberty page.


More:    Catholic League president Bill Donohue comments on lawsuits filed today against the Obama administration. At issue is the constitutionality of the Health and Human Services edict seeking to force Catholic non-profits to pay for abortion-inducing drugs, contraceptive services and sterilization in their insurance plans:

This is a great day for those who believe in religious liberty. Suing the Obama administration for seeking to trash the First Amendment rights of Catholics are 43 Catholic dioceses and institutions from all over the nation.

Among those filing suit are: the Archdiocese of New York; the Archdiocese of Washington, D.C.; the Archdiocese of St. Louis; the Diocese of Rockville Centre; the Diocese of Dallas; the Diocese of Fort Worth; the Diocese of Pittsburgh; the Diocese of Fort Wayne-South Bend; the Michigan Catholic Conference (which represents all seven dioceses in the state); Catholic University of America; Franciscan University of Steubenville; and the University of Notre Dame. Entities ranging from retirement homes to publishing houses joined the lawsuits.

There will be more. And depending on how the U.S. Supreme Court rules next month on the constitutionality of ObamaCare, this may just be the beginning.

Catholics are sending an unmistakable sign to President Obama, Kathleen Sebelius, et al. that we will not be obedient. We will not do as we are told. Instead, we will do what is just. The Catholic rebellion has begun.




  1. If only, if ONLY the Catholic church had been in this much of an uproar about the sexual crimes done against innocent children by priests, and worst of all the action/inaction of your Pope, who worked very diligently to protect the priests and protect the reputation of the church instead of doing the right thing from the very beginning. But instead the Catholic church denied, lied, and put the families of these children through hell simply for revealing the truth. Until the Catholic church stops treating the clergy like demi-gods and starts expecting them to be humble servants of the Lord and the congregation instead of pampered, protected superiors, then the Catholic church will continue to be the unwell and twisted entity that it is.

    EDITOR: Your anti-Catholic bigotry is heard loud and clear. You are obviously ill-informed and are willing to believe all the garbage put out by the main stream media who are all too willing to print anything that will denegrate the Catholic Church as well as most of
    Christianity in general. Many of the charges against the Church were made over 30, 40, and 50 years after the alleged incident. By then there were no witnesses to give testimony and often the priest accused was dead. Studies as recent as November of 2011 show that the number of priestly abuse victims were greatly exaggerated and the vast majority of the cases charged were dealing with homosexual contact not pedophilia. The Pope was not covering up anything-this was brought out into the open.
    Now if you want to be fair (and I would guess you really do not) perhaps you will look into the number of abuse cases in the Protestant and Jewish clergy. And if you really want to be open and honest then look at the enormous and skyrocketing number of abuse case proven in the public schools! The teachers are not fired but transferred to another school where they have a new crop of victims.
    I would suggest you start a study of the above mentioned items before you continue to embarrass yourself with the lies of the left.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *